photo of woman studying anatomy

Dose & Living Bodies

Radiobiology – Wikipedia

Radiobiology (also known as radiation biology, and uncommonly as actinobiology) is a field of clinical and basic medical sciences that involves the study of the action of ionizing radiation on living things, especially health effects of radiation. Ionizing radiation is generally harmful and potentially lethal to living things but can have health benefits in radiation therapy for the treatment of cancer and thyrotoxicosis. Its most common impact is the induction of cancer with a latent period of years or decades after exposure. High doses can cause visually dramatic radiation burns, and/or rapid fatality through acute radiation syndrome. Controlled doses are used for medical imaging and radiotherapy.

The following table shows radiation quantities in SI and non-SI units.

Ionizing radiation related quantities
QuantityUnitSymbolDerivationYearSI equivalence
Activity (A)becquerelBqs−11974SI unit
curieCi3.7 × 1010 s−119533.7×1010 Bq
rutherfordRd106 s−119461,000,000 Bq
Exposure (X)coulomb per kilogramC/kgC⋅kg−1 of air1974SI unit
röntgenResu / 0.001293 g of air19282.58 × 10−4 C/kg
Absorbed dose (D)grayGyJ⋅kg−11974SI unit
erg per gramerg/gerg⋅g−119501.0 × 10−4 Gy
radrad100 erg⋅g−119530.010 Gy
Equivalent dose (H)sievertSvJ⋅kg−1 × WR1977SI unit
röntgen equivalent manrem100 erg⋅g−1 x WR19710.010 Sv
Effective dose (E)sievertSvJ⋅kg−1 × WR × WT1977SI unit
röntgen equivalent manrem100 erg⋅g−1 × WR × WT19710.010 Sv
radiation quantities in SI and non-SI units

Gray (unit) – Wikipedia

Radioactivity and Ionizing Radiation

The US National Academy of Sciences Biological Effects of Ionizing Radiation Committee “has concluded that there is no compelling evidence to indicate a dose threshold below which the risk of tumor induction is zero”

PhaseSymptomWhole-body absorbed dose (Gy)
1–2 Gy2–6 Gy6–8 Gy8–30 Gy> 30 Gy
ImmediateNausea and vomiting5–50%50–100%75–100%90–100%100%
Time of onset2–6 h1–2 h10–60 min< 10 minMinutes
Duration< 24 h24–48 h< 48 h< 48 hN/A (patients die in < 48 h)
DiarrheaNoneNone to mild (< 10%)Heavy (> 10%)Heavy (> 95%)Heavy (100%)
Time of onset3–8 h1–3 h< 1 h< 1 h
HeadacheSlightMild to moderate (50%)Moderate (80%)Severe (80–90%)Severe (100%)
Time of onset4–24 h3–4 h1–2 h< 1 h
FeverNoneModerate increase (10–100%)Moderate to severe (100%)Severe (100%)Severe (100%)
Time of onset1–3 h< 1 h< 1 h< 1 h
CNS functionNo impairmentCognitive impairment 6–20 hCognitive impairment > 24 hRapid incapacitationSeizurestremorataxialethargy
Latent period 28–31 days7–28 days< 7 daysNoneNone
Illness Mild to moderate Leukopenia
Fatigue
Weakness
Moderate to severe Leukopenia
Purpura
Hemorrhage
Infections
Alopecia after 3 Gy
Severe leukopenia
High fever
Diarrhea
Vomiting
Dizziness and disorientation
Hypotension
Electrolyte disturbance
Nausea
Vomiting
Severe diarrhea
High fever
Electrolyte disturbance
Shock
N/A (patients die in < 48h)
MortalityWithout care0–5%5–95%95–100%100%100%
With care0–5%5–50%50–100%99–100%100%
Death6–8 weeks4–6 weeks2–4 weeks2 days – 2 weeks1–2 days
Radiation Exposure and Contamination – Injuries; Poisoning – Merck Manuals Professional Edition

Nuclear Regulatory Commission (nrc.gov)

0751 – H122 – Basic Health Physics – 12 – Dosimetric Quantities and Units. (nrc.gov)

The above Nuclear Regulatory Commission link would explain in detail the differences between Absorbed Dose [ gray, Gy ], and Dose Equivalent [ sievert, Sv ].

Generally speaking, we can detect ionizing radiation using Dose Rate which uses the S.I. unit of μSv/hr as a display for the ionizing radiation. Most of the time, it would be gamma rays, X-rays, through the upper energy range of the Ultraviolet electromagnetic waves that can be detected as the ionizing radiation.

Whereas, for gray (Gy), it is used as a calculated Absorbed Dose, with the known variables of the Body Tissues, and also the source of ionizing radiation. It is then reconverted back to Sv to assess the gravity of the Absorbed Dose, in Equivalent Dose (Sv).

[Formal Citations from Genicot, Jean Louis. (2014). Re: What is the difference between Sievert and Gray? A practical question concerning the SI units for ionizing radiation.. Retrieved from: https://www.researchgate.net/post/What_is_the_difference_between_Sievert_and_Gray_A_practical_question_concerning_the_SI_units_for_ionizing_radiation/5416e1a0d2fd64e71e8b45b0/citation/download. ]

Citing from Dr. Jean Louis M Genicot’s discussion reply on the differences of Sievert and Gray.

Jean Louis M Genicot

Belgian Nuclear Research Centre

The gray (Gy) is the only actual physical dose ! 1 Gy = 1J/Kg

But the effect of the radiation dose on the body changes with the radiation type. Beta and Gamma are quite equivalent but Alpha is much more dangerous.

So we use the equivalent dose to consider the danger of different radiations.

For instance, 1 Gy (1 J/kg) of Alpha is 20 times more dangerous than 1 Gy of gamma.

So 1 J/kg (physical unit) of Gamma absorbed dose corresponds to 1 Sv of equivalent dose

and

  1 J/kg (physical unit) of Alpha absorbed dose corresponds to 20 Sv of equivalent dose!

Now the different tissues of the body are differently sensitive to radiations

So we use the effective dose to consider the effect of a radiation on organs.

The ovaries are 20 times more sensitive than the skin.

For calculation:

Absorbed dose:  D (Gy)

Equivalent dose : H : Wr . D (Sv)

Effective dose:   E = Wr . Wt . D (Sv)

For simplicity, the sum of all Wt = 1

So  1 Gy of Gamma on the skin (Wr = 1, Wt = 0.01) gives 1 Sv of equivalent dose and 0.01 Sv of Effective dose.

But 1 Gy of alpha on the ovaries (Wr = 20, Wt = 0.20) gives 4 Sv of effective dose,  400 times more risky than gamma on the skin (the previous case).

There are still a lot of confusion in the use of these units because, at high doses, all radiation are deadly so the Sv is only valuable for low doses but we find publications in radiotherapy mentioning doses of 100 Sv !!!!

The sievert is used to consider the RISK of appearance of a disease. It is only statistically valuable: With a dose of 100 mSv,the risk to see a cancer in the next 20 years in two times higher than with a dose of 50 mSv BUT ONLY THE RISK maybe not the reality for a person considered alone.

A dose of 100 Sv effective dose leads certainly to the death as well as a dose of 50 Sv !!!!

Another confusion comes from the same unit (Sv) to speak about equivalent dose and effective dose.

Some people propose to use the Taylor (Ty) for the Effective dose. This is not yet approved because most of the time we know what we are speaking about.

I think that it should be useful to use different unit for different entities.

Jean Louis Genicot